|
Beijing
-- Su Ren always wondered where he would live after finishing college,
but he never considered Inner Mongolia.
Now,
because Chinese authorities' want to transfer skilled workers from the
country's booming cities to underdeveloped provinces in its "wild west,"
Su and thousands of students like him are experiencing a velvet-gloved
version of China's Maoist past -- the forced migration of workers.
"They
told me to come to a meeting in the afternoon," Su says, recounting a
phone call he received from the Beijing Institute of Technology's
recruitment office last June.
"When
I went, there were about 80 of us. They told us that if we did not get
jobs by June 30, we would have our papers sent to Inner Mongolia," says
Su, 21, who was about to graduate in engineering from the elite
university. "They didn't ask us if we wanted to go, they didn't ask us
anything. My whole life was turned upside down."
The
"papers" Su referred to are his hukou, or residence permit, and dang an,
or personal file. Together they are "China's most insidious tools of
social control," says Duan Chen Rong, a professor of demographics at the
People's University in Beijing.
A
hukou is a residence permit issued to every citizen. It determines where
a person can live. "It is like a passport for travel within China," says
Duan. The difference is that it is a restricted passport that prevents
holders from moving freely within the country.
Issued
at birth by local governments, a hukou used to require a person to
reside only within the town or district of his or her birth. Since 1984,
a loosening in rules has made it easier for people to move between
towns, but it is still difficult for an average person with a rural
hukou to get permission to move to a large city like
Beijing.
Su, who had a hukou from Xinjiang, a poor province in western China, was
one of relatively few students who beat the odds by getting into the
prestigious BIT.
The
dang an is an even more Orwellian creation of the Maoist years.
Essentially a personal file that the government maintains on every urban
citizen, a dang an records people's entire lives, including details on
what they studied, what grades they received, what work they did, how
they performed, what organizations they belong to and anything they did
that might be deemed politically incorrect.
"A
person's dang an is created when they enter primary school and
maintained until death," says Duan.
During
the Maoist era from 1949 to 1976, both the hukou and dang an controlled
the course of a person's life -- where they lived, the education they
received, which jobs they were allowed to do, even the quality of
medical care they were entitled to receive.
During
the past two decades, reforms have made the hukou and dang an less
intrusive. Some provinces have virtually stopped using them altogether.
But in many other places, they are very much alive. Su says that at his
university, authorities are using the system to inflate the employment
rate among graduates and thus make themselves look better.
"If we
don't get a job, the dang an is supposed to stay with the university or
be sent back to our hometown," Su explains. "So if my dang an is sent to
Inner Mongolia, on paper it will look like I have left university for a
job there."
Though
China's dramatic economic growth of the last two decades has raised
hundreds of millions out of poverty, the country's market-oriented
reforms have created serious inequalities, between urban and rural
areas, and between the relatively wealthy east and the more impoverished
and landlocked western provinces.
"China
has pursued an economic strategy that has favored the urban industrial
sector while exploiting the farm sector," says Kam Wing Chan, a
professor of geography at the
University
of Washington who has studied China's hukou policy for several years.
"In small towns and even some medium-sized cities, there are few, if
any, benefits attached to the local hukou.
"Having a city hukou is like having EU (European Union) citizenship.
Having a rural one is like being a citizen of a Third
World
country," says Julio Arias, an investment consultant. Such perceptions
are creating a "problem of demand and supply," says Duan of the People's
University. "The government needs skilled workers to develop backward
provinces, but skilled people don't want to go there. That is why every
year there are some students with specific skills who have to be sent
there." Duan says that in the past, small numbers of students were sent
off to "backward" areas, such as Inner
Mongolia,
because of the situation this year, thousands of students are being told
to relocate.
For Su
and his family, who had to struggle to afford the $5,000 cost of his
education, this has meant there is no cause to celebrate his graduation.
Convinced that having his papers sent out of Beijing will deny him the
chance to improve his life, Su says he will stay in the city illegally
and work as a salesman on commission for a small motor manufacturerThis
will make him one of the city's estimated 3 million illegal migrants and
will be deprived of all social benefits and excluded from prime
employment opportunities.
It is
a bleak future, but one he prefers to forced relocation to Inner
Mongolia.
"My
family was already forced to move once. In 1962 they had to go to
Xinjiang because of a famine in Henan.
Life there was tough," says Su. "I really wanted a career in Beijing so
I could earn enough to take care of my family." |